Running a contingency practice means betting on your own cases, and the bills for that bet arrive long before the payoff. Law school rarely covers how to manage that stretch, so most attorneys learn it the hard way. This post walks through it in plain language for the attorneys, office managers, and finance leads who keep the firm running while cases work their way toward resolution.
When you advance case costs, you’re fronting the money and waiting for resolution to be repaid. The ABA Model Rules allow that, as long as your fee agreement is in writing and settlement funds are handled carefully. The rest comes down to three habits: knowing what you’ve spent, knowing what’s coming next, and treating a settlement as cash only once it’s actually cash. Rules vary by state, so use this as a starting point and check your own.
A vendor invoice has a due date. A settlement doesn’t.
That’s the unspoken tension in running a firm on contingency. Filing fees, records requests, expert retainers, mediator fees, and deposition transcripts all get billed on someone else’s schedule. Your fee arrives when the case resolves, and that date depends on the court calendar, the pace of negotiations, and any approvals or liens that have to clear. Payroll and rent, meanwhile, arrive on the first of the month with perfect punctuality.
Law school covers a lot. Cash forecasting for a practice that fronts its own case costs is rarely on the syllabus. Most contingency lawyers learn it by doing, usually the first time a strong case sits in discovery while the cost ledger keeps growing.
If your cash flow has ever depended on a mediation going well, this one’s for you.
Key Takeaways
The short answer is that you’re funding the case before it pays you back. Under a contingency fee agreement, the firm covers the cost of building the case and gets repaid from the recovery. Those costs tend to climb in the middle of a case, well before settlement talks get serious. The stretch where you’re spending the most is often the stretch where you’ve collected the least.
Tax timing can make it feel heavier. Under the cash method, you generally report income in the tax year you receive it and deduct expenses in the tax year you pay them. A year with heavy case spending and few resolutions can look thin on paper. Your CPA can help you plan for those swings.
You can do it, as long as the paperwork is right.
Model Rule 1.8(e) generally bars a lawyer from giving a client financial assistance in connection with pending or contemplated litigation. The exception is the one contingency lawyers rely on. You may advance court costs and expenses of litigation, with repayment contingent on the outcome.
Model Rule 1.5(c) covers the paperwork. The contingent fee agreement must be in writing and signed by the client. It also has to explain how the fee is determined, list expenses to be deducted from the recovery, and say whether those expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated. That last choice affects both your fee and the client’s net, so it’s worth modeling both versions before anything is signed.
State rules vary, so check your current rule before building policy around the model text.
Fee caps can also limit your revenue. The Federal Tort Claims Act, for example, limits attorney fees to no more than 25% of a judgment or litigation settlement or 20% of an administrative settlement. Some states set their own limits. Forecast with the capped percentage, not the one you wish applied.
You can’t know when a case will resolve. You can know what it has cost so far and what the next stage will likely cost.
Start at intake with a rough cost budget for the case, then revisit it at each stage. Every stage brings its own expenses, and a budget you update as the case moves will serve you better than one you wrote on day one and filed away.
Next, add up what the whole docket has advanced. For a contingency firm, that number is the capital you have at work across every open case. A simple spreadsheet with one row per case and a running total of dollars advanced is enough to start.
From there, build a rolling 13-week cash forecast. List what you expect to pay out each week, including payroll, rent, vendor invoices, and upcoming case costs, along with what you can reasonably expect to come in. Update it weekly and roll it forward. Say your firm has advanced $18,000 across six open cases, an expert retainer is due on one, and payroll lands on the first. A forecast shows that tight week a month ahead, which leaves time to ask a vendor about timing instead of scrambling.
The income side takes the most discipline. Treat a settlement as cash once the agreement and release are signed. A verbal yes at mediation is encouraging, but it won’t cover payroll. Even after signing, funds need to clear and be disbursed, so build that lag into your forecast.
Finally, keep a reserve. Some firms hold about three months of fixed overhead, though the right number depends on your docket and how long your cases typically run.
You control more than you might realize. You can’t move a vendor’s invoice date, but you can decide when you incur the expense.
Ask at each stage whether the next large expense is needed now or can wait for what the previous step produces. A records request might narrow which experts you need. A deposition might change which witnesses are worth the next round. Cancellation fees add up, and expedited transcripts often cost more than standard delivery, so order them only when a deadline requires it.
Sometimes. And it never hurts to ask.
Many vendors bill on 30-day terms. Many contingency cases run far longer than that. Before a large expense, ask vendors what flexibility they offer, and get the answer in writing.
At Steno, DelayPay allows firms to defer court reporting and litigation support costs until your case concludes. Whatever provider you use, read the terms so you know what you owe and when you owe it.
A signed release and money in your account arrive on different days, and the days in between matter.
When a lawyer receives funds in which a client has an interest, Rule 1.15 requires prompt notice to the client, delivery of what the client is owed, and an accounting on request. If any portion is disputed, those disputed funds stay in trust while the rest is distributed. Some states add requirements, so be sure to check those specific requirements.
The timing can get tight. A settlement deposit can land the same week payroll is due, and the money looks like operating cash. Until the closing statement is complete and the funds are disbursed, though, the money sits in the trust account, and the firm’s share is not yet the firm’s to spend. When the pull to use it is strong, remember that a tight week is much easier to recover from than a trust account violation.
You can shorten the wait by reconciling each case’s cost ledger monthly, keeping a closing statement template ready, and using a checklist:
Finding a $1,200 records invoice on disbursement day is a bad surprise for everyone. Set aside an hour a month to reconcile ledgers, update your forecast, and review what’s due. It’s not exciting work. But it keeps your first thought on the case when a mediator calls to say the other side is finally ready to talk.
What Is the cash flow gap for contingency-based firms?
It is the stretch between paying case costs and collecting a fee. Contingency-based firms advance expenses such as filing fees, records requests, expert retainers, and deposition transcripts, then get paid when the case resolves. Payroll and rent come due on a fixed schedule in the meantime. Firms on the cash method generally report income when received and deduct expenses when paid, so the gap also shows up in tax reporting.
Can a law firm advance case costs under the ABA Model Rules?
Yes. ABA Model Rule 1.8(e) generally bars financial assistance to clients in pending or contemplated litigation, but it allows a lawyer to advance court costs and expenses of litigation, with repayment contingent on the outcome. Some states modify the rule, so check your jurisdiction’s current version.
What does a contingency fee agreement have to say about expenses?
Under Model Rule 1.5(c), the agreement must be in writing and signed by the client, state how the fee is determined, list expenses to be deducted from the recovery, and say whether those expenses come out before or after the fee is calculated. That last choice changes both the firm’s fee and the client’s net recovery, so model each version before signing.
How should a contingency-based firm forecast cash flow?
Start by budgeting costs at intake and updating them at each case stage. Track total dollars advanced across the docket, run a rolling 13-week cash forecast, and count a settlement as incoming cash only after the agreement and release are signed. Many firms also hold a reserve, such as three months of fixed overhead.
Can a firm use settlement funds to cover payroll before disbursement?
No. Under Model Rule 1.15, a lawyer who receives funds in which a client has an interest must promptly notify the client, deliver what is owed, and account for it on request, and disputed funds stay in trust while the rest is distributed. Settlement money is client money until the closing statement is complete and the funds are disbursed. Some states add requirements, so confirm yours with your state bar.
Curious about what Steno can do for your firm? Book a demo.
This post is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice. Rules vary by jurisdiction, so confirm requirements with your state bar and your CPA.