In Part 1, Patty stopped into Depot Print Shop to pick up an order and slipped on paper stock an employee had left in the customer walkway. She fractured her wrist and had to temporarily close Naturally Leavened, the small bakery that she owns and manages. She hired Amanda Ruiz, a personal injury attorney, who confirmed she has a viable negligence claim against Depot Print Shop. Now the real work begins.
Amanda knows Patty has a claim. What she doesn’t have yet is the paper trail to prove it—the documents, records, and witness accounts that will form the factual backbone of everything that follows.
Before she requests a single record, Amanda sends a preservation letter, also known as a litigation hold, to both the opposing party and her own client. This formal notice directs them to retain all records related to the incident. Once a party is on notice of potential litigation, they have a legal obligation to preserve relevant evidence. Amanda needs to lock that evidence down before she can go looking for it.
Destroying or concealing evidence after a litigation hold notice is called spoliation, and courts take it seriously. A judge might instruct a jury to infer that the missing evidence would have been unfavorable to the party who lost it, impose monetary sanctions on the party or their counsel, or, in egregious cases, even dismiss the spoliating party’s claims entirely.
With the hold in place, the investigation can begin. That means gathering everything connected to the incident: witness interviews, incident reports, medical records, financial records, photographs, surveillance footage, and anything else that helps reconstruct what happened. This is only preliminary fact gathering. A more formal discovery process, to be covered later, is much more expansive.
With the key facts assembled, Amanda is ready to make her next move. Before filing an official lawsuit, most plaintiffs’ attorneys send a demand letter to the opposing party. This formal attempt to resolve the dispute without a lawsuit typically contains:
Amanda’s letter to Depot Print Shop lays out the incident clearly, identifies the company’s liability, and provides her estimate of Patty’s damages. She also flags the possibility of additional damages as her investigation continues. This reserves her right to adjust the amount of damages she’s seeking if, for example, a physical therapist later determines that Patty will never regain full mobility in her wrist.
The demand letter also functions as a deadline. Amanda gives Depot Print Shop thirty days to respond. Their options are to pay the demand, propose a counteroffer, or ignore the letter entirely and wait to see if a lawsuit is actually filed. Some demand letters are bluffs, sent with no intention of following up with a lawsuit.
Amanda is not bluffing, as Depot Print Shop’s attorneys will soon realize.
The demand letter’s opening bid often kicks off a negotiation. In cases like this one involving businesses, negotiation might be handled by the company’s insurer. Most companies carry liability insurance for situations like this and, once on notice of a potential lawsuit, the insurer steps in to manage exposure.
Depot Print Shop’s insurer wants to close the claim for as little as possible and Amanda wants to close the claim for as much as possible. Ideally, they’d reach a settlement agreement pre-lawsuit, which resolves things more quickly, more privately, and with less uncertainty. Litigation is expensive and slow, and case filings become public record. Juries are unpredictable and their verdicts can turn on factors other than the merits of the case, like sympathy, presentation, or narrative.
Not every negotiation, however, produces a deal. The insurer’s counteroffers are too low. The gap between what Patty needs and what Depot Print Shop will pay is too wide, so the negotiations break down. Amanda has no choice but to file.
Pre-litigation ends one of two ways: a settlement agreement or a complaint. This one will end with a complaint.
Amanda has kept Patty informed throughout—a phone call after the preservation letter went out, another when the demand letter was sent, a brief update when the insurer’s first counteroffer came back low. Amanda doesn’t over-communicate. She surfaces what Patty needs to know, tells her plainly what it means, and moves on. Patty has learned not to expect hand-holding, and has come to appreciate that about her attorney. Back at Naturally Leavened, she’s managing the morning rush on a wrist that still isn’t right, watching the calendar, and waiting.
In the next installment of Paper Trail, Amanda will draft and file Patty’s formal complaint, the document that officially initiates the lawsuit. We’ll cover what goes in it, how it’s filed, and what happens the moment it hits the court’s docket.
Book a demo to discover how Steno can support your team throughout the litigation process.